Salted Dark Chocolate Pudding

Salted Dark Chocolate Pudding | In Jennie's Kitchen

I grew up on packaged instant pudding, and that was fine for the first 20 years of my life. Then I tasted the homemade stuff during my tenure at Gramercy Tavern. My world was forever changed. It’s no surprise this Salted Dark Chocolate Pudding is one of the first desserts I began making at the restaurant in Hudson when I started there a few months ago.

I realize as we turn our thoughts to swimsuit season, pudding is probably the last thing on your mind. I felt the same way a few weeks ago as I prepared for our trip to Florida. Life is too short to sweat this stuff, though, and I think everything is fine in moderation. 

This recipe might look familiar if you ordered the spring issue of Simple Scratch Cooking two years ago. It’s been a long time, I know, since the last issue was released. I’m not completely sure when, or even if, that will happen. Homeschooling took over a big chunk of my time these last nice months, and any free time I had was devoted to working on a big cookbook project I delivered in March. Another ghost development project, of which I’m very proud, and will let you know when I have more information to share about it.

But back to this Salted Dark Chocolate Pudding. Making pudding isn’t difficult, but it is the kind of recipe that requires some patience.

Ever wonder why pudding recipes call for stirring some of the hot milk into the eggs before adding them to the pan? The process is referred to as tempering, and it’s a technique used to gently cook the egg yolks. Don’t be tempted to skip this important step, or your yolks will likely curdle or scramble in to the milk mixture, resulting in a loss of time and ingredients.

Salted Dark Chocolate Pudding | In Jennie's Kitchen

Patience is also key in making pudding, especially if you decide to double the recipe, which I do often at the restaurant. At first, it’ll seem the pudding isn’t thickening, and then presto, it’s perfect. That moment really does seem to happen instantly, but it’s patience that yields the reward.

I’ve been known to layer this with some homemade caramel sauce. Candied pistachios make a great topping, too. Perhaps I’ll share the recipe for making those one day soon. And I’m tempted to say whipped cream is optional, but no sense in kidding ourselves, right? Try my Orange Scented Whipped Cream or Violet Scented Whipped Cream for extra oomph.

Eight Years Ago: Classic Sangria

Seven Years Ago: Whole Grain Pizza

Six Years Ago: Dairy-Free Carrot Cupcakes

Five Years Ago: Crispy Chewy Walnut Cookies

Four Years Ago: Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble

Three Years Ago: Eating Our Way Through Philly

Two Years Ago: Perfect Chocolate Chip Cookies

One Year Ago: Strawberry Rhubarb Margarita

This recipe is now part of my new site, Simmering. It can be found here.



  • Marilyn

    Wow! I read this and went directly to my kitchen and made a batch. It is delicious and would be even better with the darker cocoa powder (which I didn’t have!) Thanks for the great recipe.

  • Marcela

    5 stars
    When I started reading … I thought it was going to be difficult. But no!! I already saved the recipe, it looks delicious.

  • Theresa Davila

    Definitely need your help please. We can’t use dairy and have tried making pudding with almond milk with no success. Is there any tantalizing magic you can share? Would love to make this again. Thank you

  • Jennie

    I can’t say for sure if this would work wit almond milk, Theresa, but you’ve inspired me to give it a try. I’ll let you know how it turns out. -Jennie

  • Marilyn

    5 stars
    Updated comment: I froze some of this in Popsicle molds & it is wonderful frozen!

  • Jennie

    It’s a type of salt. You can swap in your table salt, if that’s all you have on hand.

  • Heather

    In lieu of almond milk (nut allergy), I have successfully made pudding with coconut milk. Leaves a coconutty flavor, but that plays nicely with chocolate. Best of luck!