Spicy Honey Mustard Sauce

I love honey mustard dipping sauce. In researching recipes, though, it seems mayonnaise is a key ingredient. I’ll willingly eat something already made at a restaurant, but my relationship with mayo at home is a complicated one. I can’t quite wrap my head around how something with eggs in it can be shelf stable, requiring no refrigeration until open. This is why there are so many stabilizers and extra added ingredients in jarred mayonnaise.

Offering up a science lesson will do you no good. Mayonnaise and I have had this rocky relationship for decades now, and it won’t be changing any time soon. So, you can understand the quandary I found myself in when I wanted to make a honey mustard sauce for my fried chicken bites, but didn’t feel like adding the extra step of making my own mayonnaise.

That’s when I decided to throw the conventional honey mustard sauce recipe rulebook out the window.

I would make honey mustard sauce on my own terms. The bonus is that my honey mustard sauce recipe is egg free.

Now, I know a few of you are giving me the eye roll for the cilantro in this recipe. Calm down. You don’t have to use it, and no need to substitute another herb. Just leave it out all together. If you love cilantro as much as I do, then you will adore this honey mustard sauce with it. Feel free to make this as spicy or mild as you want. You can even leave the hot sauce out all together, if you prefer.

Spicy Honey Mustard Sauce | In Jennie's Kitchen


This recipe is now available to paid subscribers on my site, Simmering.  Join thousands of other subscribers now for as little as $2.50/month. Use this link for a special 15% discount on annual subscriptions for being a loyal reader of In Jennie’s Kitchen (that’s only $25.50/year!).



  • Barbara

    Well….this sounds amazing!! I’m grilling burgers for dinner — I think I’ll make this & add it to the beef before making patties.

  • Barbara

    It was :- ) The burgers were deliciously sweet and sooo moist – maybe too much, because they kind of crumbled. But that certainly wasn’t a deal breaker for us, because we eat our burgers with forks anyways (no wheat) unless I make sweet potato buns, which I didn’t. I hope you try it, but maybe add an egg to hold the beef together. Thanks for the inspiration!!