chewy, bittersweet brownies

I found myself craving brownies the other night, which rarely happens. I must confess that while I love baking chocolate desserts (they generally make everyone happy!), they are not my first choice for eating. I reached for my copy of Homemade with Love to make the walnut fudge brownies on page 185. Honestly, it still blows my mind, and humbles me, every time I pull my own cookbook off the shelf.  A quick scan of the ingredients, and I realized I didn’t have any espresso granules in the house. I decided to brew up a small pot of very strong coffee in its place. While I was at it, I swapped in whole wheat pastry flour for the all-purpose, and used less, too. You can use regular all-purpose flour if that’s all you have on hand, and it’ll be fine. I just figured I’d fool myself into believing the whole wheat would make them healthier.

A smidge more sugar to balance out the dark chocolate, and away went the nuts completely. I seriously considered topping them with chopped pistachios because they were M’s favorite. It came down to the wire really, the very last minute, before the pan went into the oven, that I settled on no nuts at all.

The real game changer here is the kind of salt I used. On my last trip to Paris, I brought back two sacks of fleur de sel from Poilâne. If you ever go there, the salt is an incredible bargain at only 3,5€ for one kilo, and the flavor of the salt is exceptional. Well, that salt made all the difference, its taste very prominent in the brownies, but in a good way. The crunch of the flakes feel like savory pop rocks as they burst on your tongue.

One last bit of advice, if you can manage any type of self-control, let them sit out for a good half a day to cool completely. They become more compact, settling into a chewy, dense brownie. My suggestion is to make them at night, like I did, so you don’t have to torture yourself waiting for them to cool. And if you decide to eat one for breakfast, well, I applaud you for stopping at just one—I ate two. Okay, three.

bittersweet brownies |

Chewy Bittersweet Brownies

makes 16 – 2-inch pieces

Music Pairing: In a Sentimental Mood by Duke Ellington & John Coltrane

I know a lot of people are anti-microwave, but I find it super convenient for melting chocolate. You could do that step in a double boiler on the stovetop, if you prefer.

As for the sugar measurement, it’s a finicky one, I know, but really is the proper amount. Look at it as incentive to get a scale, and bake by weight—then you can just measure everything directly into the bowl!

Last, but most definitely not least, let’s talk about the chocolate. As with anything you set out to cook, the quality of the ingredients will affect the final flavor. The chocolate discs and cocoa powder should be of the best quality possible, and the cocoa should most definitely be dark. You can use regular cocoa, but the color will not be as dark, and the taste will not be as intense. I never like to be so rigid in the kitchen, but do want you to be aware that making substitutions will result in something different, so consider this my disclaimer. I use these Guittard bittersweet chocolate discs, but Valrhona or Callebaut would be good, too. The cocoa powder I use is from Guittard also, but I can’t seem to find it online; I get it at a store by my house. Valrhona makes one that is dark, too, which I think may be more readily available. I also see King Arthur has a black cocoa, which I’m sure will work, though I’ve not used it.

This recipe is now available to paid subscribers on my site, Simmering.  Join thousands of other subscribers now for only $5/month or $30/year (that’s six months free!). Use this link for a special 15% discount on annual subscriptions for being a loyal reader of In Jennie’s Kitchen (that’s only $25.50/year!).


  • Gillian

    I have a combo of your two recipes in the oven right now! I use the cookbook one all. the. time.

    I used Amedei chocolate, smoked Maldon salt and a splash of bourbon as I didn’t feel like making coffee 🙂

  • anthea

    Hi Jennifer!
    love the site AND the cookbook. A question please. When I melt chocolate in dble-boiler (no microwave) to coat a cookie or dip a biscotti in it’s always WAY too thick. I’m cautious with it as I don’t want it too hot, I don’t stir it too much either. Any thoughts?

    JP’s Note: May I ask if you’re using a true double boiler with two pots that fit snugly together, or using a bowl fitted over a pot? I’ve found this make a big difference, because with the bowl-pot method, there is the possibility for moisture to creep up over into the bowl which affects the melting process. That’s exactly why I personally prefer using the microwave. Perfect melted chocolate every time, provided you do it in 30 second increments. If you melt chocolate often, and do like microwave, it might worth it to invest in a proper double boiler.

  • Alicia @ Weekly Greens

    My first baking-by-weight experience was your chewy ginger snaps. Divine. The boys loved them so much we left a few for Santa on Christmas Eve. This will be my second project using the kitchen scale to measure dry ingredients. I’m having “date night” at home with the littles while Daddy is out of town – I promised them steak, homemade fries (the “real” kind not the oven kind -eeeeek!) and I think brownies are a natural finish after all that. They’ll be delighted!

  • Liesl

    Dear Jennie,
    Thank you for this post and most of all for your writing. This comment is not specifically related to this post, but I want to let you know that my father died 6 days ago, and while he was not very young, the grief in missing him is huge. I find comfort in your writing and your blog in general and am so glad that you continue to write and that it is here for me now.

    JP’s Note: Liesl, I’m so sorry to hear your news. Young vs. older, it doesn’t matter. Any loss of someone you love deeply is devastating. I’m glad I can offer comfort in what I share here, and thank you for making my words part of your days. Sending you lots of love from Brooklyn. -Jennie

  • Anna

    Thanks for a great recipe Jennie! Although brownies are supposed to be the easiest things to make, they never turn out well for me. But these were perfect – exactly the right mix of chewy/cakey! I didn’t have coffee on hand so I used dark rum. So good!

  • Wendy

    I am making these this week! They seem like the perfect gift for my son’s teachers. Today I am home sick and am also going to make your pizza dough – turned into bread (instagram).
    Thank you for sharing such delicious recipes.