peach blueberry cobbler cake

A rainy day on Cape Cod beats a sunny day in Brooklyn. It’s a good thing the Mr. and I are in agreement on this one, since it’s been grey and wet for the past three days. Even in the rain, though, North Truro is picture perfect, as evidenced in this view of Provincetown from our deck. The sun was struggling to peek out near dusk. All that managed to escape were a few rays, casting a heavenly glow over Pilgrim Monument.


The inspiration for this peach blueberry cobbler cake started with a lazy afternoon on the couch watching Giada make a fruit crumble on the Food Network. An indulgence since I never watch it at home. All day, I’d been staring at some peaches that I’d brought from Brooklyn. The owner at a local shop gave them to me from his backyard the day before we left. I’d been wanting to make a cobbler but didn’t have enough.

Besides, I must confess, I rarely bake on vacation. There are so many sweets I look forward to on our annual trip—donuts at Flemings, trutas and malasadas at the Provincetown Portuguese Bakery, birthday cake ice cream from Sweet Escape. Still, the urge to create became overwhelming.

I decided to add some blueberries to the mix. With this addition I would’ve had enough to make a traditional cobbler, but truth be told I love the idea of cobblers more than the eating them. Being a cake fiend, there’s never enough topping for my taste. I decided to take my recipe for biscuits, add a bit more buttermilk and fold the fruit into the batter.

Best part is I didn’t need an special tools—my fingertips did the job of a food processor, and the prep took all of 10 minutes, including dicing the peaches. FYI, I leave the skins on—you can peel them if you prefer, but honestly the skins weren’t even noticeable in the finished cake.

Now I’m off to watch Escape to With Mountain with Isabella while the baby naps. Hope you’re all enjoying these last days of summer vacation.


This recipe is now part of my new site, Simmering. Join thousands of other subscribers now for only $5/month or $30/year (that’s six months free!)


  • UrMomCooks

    This looks yummy! Doesn’t buttermilk make everything better??? I am going to keep eating peaches and blueberries as long as I can — this recipe looks delicious!

  • To Kiss the Cook

    I’m so glad you’re having fun and I totally agree- I actually love a good rainy day on the Cape. Galleries and movies in Wellfleet and lobster shack runs and video games at the Red Barn…the air smells so so good. If you manage a night out for a date while you’re in town, I’ve fallen in love with Blackfish in Truro.

  • Liz the Chef

    Love the combo of peaches and blueberries – hope you are enjoying your vacation…I’m making making more of your delicious tomato jam 😉

  • Jill

    Love your site and just happened upon this recipe from a couple years ago. Definitely making it for family dinner tonight! Thanks! (P.S. Checked your cookbook out of the library last month – after a LONG wait…it’s clearly popular! After paging through it once over coffee I decided I must own it – and now have a copy of my own. Love it!)

  • Zach

    Hi, I tried to make this and it was SUPER doughy in the middle! What happened? We baked it. Let it cool, refrigerated it, heated it at supper, and it was like mush. We baked it again at 400 for 10 minutes…still mush. It’s in the oven again now.

    Serve hot or cold?? Gah. The batter tastes good though!!

  • Jennifer Perillo

    Hi Zach,

    Can you tell me more about how you prepared the recipe? Did you follow the ingredients, and instructions exactly, or did you make any changes/substitutions? Also, do you know if your oven is properly calibrated (cooks at the right temperature)? It is more common than you would think for ovens to run colder, or hotter, than what the actual dial or digital display reads. My apologies for not including a tip I usually add to my cake recipes, which is to test it with a toothpick or metal skewer for doneness. You insert it into the center, and pull it out to make sure the center of the cake is fully cooked. It’s okay if a few crumbs stick to the skewer, but if there is raw batter, then that’s an indication that the cake needs to bake longer.