Creamy Homemade Ricotta

I first tasted homemade ricotta about 10 years ago. It was quite revelatory. Creamy, almost buttery, bits of cheese, full of flavor that melt in your mouth. Nothing at all like the watery stuff I grew up eating off supermarket shelves. I hadn’t given much thought to making it myself until just recently—like last Thursday. Truth be told, I can’t remember if I’m coming or going these days, so I couldn’t tell you what brought on the urge exactly. I just remember waking up thinking I want to make ricotta. This is here Google comes in real handy. Imagine how much quicker we would’ve evolved if cavemen could’ve googled “how to make fire”?

Anywho, a quick search showed a few variations in ingredients, but the basic chemical reaction (curdling the milk) required two things: milk and an acid. Some recipes called for lemon, others white vinegar. The one that struck me was Heidi Swanson’s over at 101 Cookbooks. Her’s called for buttermilk, and it was really genius. Buttermilk naturally contains lactic acid.

While Heidi’s recipe was simply buttermilk and whole milk, I liked David Lebovitz’s use of cream. I had a hunch it would produce that buttery flavor I was looking for, so I scaled back some of the milk to add it. Not only was I incredibly happy with the outcome, I also learned it’s ridiculously easy to make from scratch. Now I don’t have to worry that my favorite Italian shops are closed on Sunday or Monday. I can enjoy homemade ricotta all the time. Another perk is eating it still warm from the colander—topped with some homemade strawberry or tomato jam. Next time I’m going to make it with the kids as a tasty science lesson.


Creamy Homemade Ricotta

makes about 2 cups plus a few spoonfuls for taste testing

Keep in mind the ricotta will thicken in the fridge, so don’t drain it too much, or it’ll end up dry and cakey. I also like to let it come to room temperature before serving.

4 cups whole milk

1 cup heavy cream

3/4 cup buttermilk

1/2 teaspoon salt

Add ingredients to a 4-quart pot. Bring to a gentle boil over medium heat. Meanwhile, line a sieve or fine mesh strainer with a few layers of cheesecloth and place it over a deep bowl or pot.


Once curds begin to separate from the whey (liquid temperature will be between 175º and 200º), remove from heat. Gently spoon or ladle the curds into the cheesecloth-lined strainer. You may need to gently gather the cheesecloth at the top to help the curds drain. 




Let curds sit in cheesecloth to drain liquid 15 to 30 minutes, depending on how creamy you’d like your ricotta. Store in refrigerator up to two days.